Federal Vs. Private Student Loans

ESB Professional/Shutterstock

Federal and private student loans are two options that students can use to pay for college when other forms of aid fall short. While federal loans are only available through the federal government, private student loans can come from other lenders. It’s important to choose between federal vs. private student loans, as each has different interest rates, repayment terms, hardship options and fees.

In most cases, federal student loans are preferable because of the benefits they come with. But if you’ve maxed out your federal loans, it may be worth considering private student loans.

Federal vs. private student loans at a glance

Rates for federal student loans are fixed and tend to be lower than private student loans. Federal student loans are known for their loan forgiveness options. However, federal student loans may have lower loan amounts than private.

Federal student loans

Federal student loans are educational loans that are available through the U.S. Department of Education. For each type of loan, the interest rate is the same for all borrowers. Federal loans also come with a variety of benefits that can make your repayment plan more affordable. That said, they are almost always the best form of financing to cover higher education costs if you qualify.

There are a few main types of federal student loans:

• Direct Subsidized Loans: are available for undergraduate students with financial need, and they cover all accrued interest while you’re in school and during deferment and grace periods.
• Direct Unsubsidized Loans: don’t cover your interest, but they’re available for both undergraduate and graduate students, regardless of financial need.
• Direct PLUS Loans: are offered to graduate students and parents of dependent undergraduate students, and they’re the only type that doesn’t have a dollar-amount cap on how much you can borrow.

Benefits of federal student loans

Federal student loans have several benefits:

• Access to student loan forgiveness: Federal student loans offer access to different loan forgiveness programs, such as Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) and Teacher Loan Forgiveness. If you qualify for any of these programs, you could end up having tens of thousands of dollars in student loan debt forgiven once you meet the requirements.
• Access to income-driven repayment plans: The Department of Education offers several income-driven repayment plans, which can reduce your monthly payment to as little as 10 percent of your discretionary income. If you struggle to make your monthly payments, these plans can be a huge lifesaver.
• Few to no credit requirements: Most federal student loans don’t require a credit check at all. With Direct PLUS Loans, a credit check is used only to determine if you have certain negative items on your credit history, such as bankruptcy. If you haven’t had the chance to build a credit history, you will still qualify for federal loans.
• Discharge in the event of loss or disability: If you become permanently disabled, your federal student loan balance is automatically discharged. Loan discharge also occurs in the event of the student’s or the parent’s death (if they took a parent PLUS loan).
• Generally cheaper: For most students, federal student loans are likely cheaper than private student loans. This is especially true for undergraduate students who don’t have a stable source of income or a long credit history.

Drawbacks of federal student loans

Although there are some clear benefits to using federal loans, here are some potential pitfalls to watch out for:

• Upfront fees: The federal government charges an upfront loan fee on all of its loan products. The fee is relatively low for undergraduate students but high for graduate and professional students, as well as for parents.
• Loan limits: Undergraduate students are limited in how much they can borrow, which may require them to ultimately turn to private student loans to bridge the gap.
• No choice of servicer: When you apply for federal student loans, the Department of Education assigns a loan servicer to you automatically. If you have a bad experience, you can consolidate your loans with another servicer, but the consolidation process can impact your access to certain benefits and protections.

Private student loans

Private student loans are educational loans offered by private lenders, like banks, credit unions and online companies. They require a credit check, and your approval and loan terms are dependent on your creditworthiness. It may be challenging for many students to get approved for private loans independently, but applying with a co-signer may improve the chances.

Benefits of private student loans

Although it’s best for most students to start with federal student loans, there are some advantages to using private loans if necessary:

• Higher loan amounts: Loan limits can vary from lender to lender, but you can generally get up to the total cost of attendance, giving you more borrowing power than with the federal government.
• Chance for low interest rates: If you’re a graduate or professional student or a parent, it is possible to get a lower interest rate through a private lender than through the federal government if you have excellent credit — sometimes three or four percentage points lower than the federal rate. Starting rates can also be lower, meaning it can be a good option if you can pay the loan off quickly.
• No upfront fees: Private lenders typically don’t charge upfront loan fees on private student loans, giving you savings right off the bat.
• Loan terms are more flexible: The standard term for a federal student loan is 10 years, whereas private terms may be five to 20 years.

Drawbacks of private student loans

Before taking out a private student loan, consider some of the downsides:

• Lack of protections: Private lenders don’t offer student loan forgiveness programs, and most of them don’t offer income-driven repayment plans. You may be able to get on a forbearance plan if you end up struggling financially, but options for lowering your monthly payment on a permanent basis are scarce.
• High interest rates for most: Because private loans require a credit check, people with no credit history or a low credit score may end up with a more expensive loan than what the federal government offers — and that’s if you qualify for a private loan in the first place.
• Have to search for your own loans: You can apply for a federal student loan right through your school’s FAFSA application. You need to find private loans through lender websites.

Federal vs. private loan: What type of student loan is best for me?

Many people wonder: are federal student loans better than private? But the answer to this question depends on your unique financial situation. Still, federal student loans are generally the best starting point for most college students and their parents. These loans come with protections and benefits, like fixed interest rates, subsidies and repayment programs, that can’t be matched by private lenders. However, there are a few instances when you should consider private student loans.

For example, if you’ve exhausted the federal student loan limit, private loans could finance the remainder of your education. And if you’re a graduate or professional college student or a parent facing higher interest rates on federal loans, it might not hurt to shop around and compare rates with various private lenders to determine if you can get a better offer.

In the end, the best student loan for you comes down to your financial health, the amount you need to borrow for school and how quickly you anticipate paying back the loan. It’s equally important to consider borrowing costs, along with the repayment options available to you.

If you can pay back your loan quickly and can qualify for a low interest rate, a private student loan may be best. If you’d like to take advantage of income-driven repayment plans, extensive deferment programs and potential loan forgiveness, a federal student loan is the best option.

Bottom line

Whether you’re a college student or a parent of a college student, federal and private student loans are available to help fund education. It’s usually best to use federal student loans to meet your financing needs, but there are some instances where it can be worthwhile to consider private loans.

Take your time examining all of your options, looking at the differences between private and federal student loans, and how they might affect you now and in the future so you can make the best financial decision for you.

Frequently asked questions

• Can I take out federal and private student loans?

  Parents and students can take out private and federal student loans at the same time. In fact, many borrowers have some of both. Dependent students, for instance, can take out only $5,500 in federal student loans in their first year of college, which may fall well short of their total educational costs.In this scenario, taking out a private loan and a federal loan may be the only way to cover those costs. If you do take out a mix of both federal and private loans, be aware that some of your loan details may look similar; several student loan servicers manage both federal and private loans, so you may work with the same servicer for two different types of loans.

• Is it hard to qualify for federal student loans?

  Borrowers with federal student loans typically have more flexible options available for repayment. Some loans (direct subsidized) also do not accrue interest while the borrower is in school, during grace periods, or during forbearance.  Federal loan borrowers may also be eligible for loan forgiveness.For these reasons and others, federal loans are the best and first option for many.  For borrowers with excellent credit or a co-borrower, it may be possible to find a lower interest rate with private student loans. Students who have hit the borrowing limit for federal student loans, or who may not be eligible for federal loans, may also find solutions with private loans.

• What happens if I don’t qualify for federal student loans?

  Federal loan denial can happen for a number of reasons, but there are still options for financing a higher education. Check with your institution’s financial aid office to see if you are eligible for grants or scholarships to help with costs. In addition, you may still be eligible for private student loans, which you can apply for separately.